Nyquist faces fellow undefeated Kentucky Derby hopeful Mohaymen in Saturday's Florida Derby. (Photo by Leslie Martin/Coglianese Photo)
By Tom Pedulla, America's Best Racing
HALLANDALE BEACH, Fla. – When owner J. Paul Reddam was asked if Nyquist would still be confronting Mohaymen in the $1-million Xpressbet.com Florida Derby if a $1-million bonus was not also at stake on Saturday at Gulfstream Park, his answer was anything but direct.
“I would like to think we would still be there,” Reddam said during a phone interview. “But if we’re honest, it’s hard to say. I don’t know.”
The certainty is that participation in the Florida Derby represents a high-risk, high-reward proposition for Reddam, a former professor of philosophy at California State University, Los Angeles. The risk begins with having the Breeders’ Cup Juvenile winner and 2-year-old champion having to leave the physical and psychological comfort of his home base at Santa Anita Park to face the saltiest opponent out there on that foe’s home course.
Beyond that, the logistics mean Nyquist will not ship home to begin preparations for the May 7 Kentucky Derby Presented by Yum! Brands. Once he is given a little time to recover from the most arduous prep race the owner and trainer Doug O’Neill could find, he will head to Keeneland Race Course in Lexington, Ky., to train for the most important start of his career.
It is fair to say the weather in Lexington in April is not nearly as dependable as the Southern California sunshine, seemingly creating training conditions far less ideal than what O’Neill is accustomed to as he continues to develop a youngster whose ability to get the classic mile-and-a-quarter distance is being questioned.
Given that risk, Reddam, who purchased Nyquist for $400,000 as a 2-year-old, and O’Neill have been intent on chasing the reward almost as soon as the Uncle Mo colt scored an impressive victory in the Juvenile at Keeneland. With Nyquist qualifying for the $1-million bonus being offered to any graduate of Fasig-Tipton’s Florida sale who wins the Florida Derby, the windfall would be $1.6 million. No other prep race, no Triple Crown race, offers such a massive return.
Reddam appears to be profoundly influenced by his wild emotional ride with 2012 Kentucky Derby and Preakness winner I’ll Have Another. Their much-anticipated Triple Crown bid never reached the starting gate. I’ll Have Another was scratched on the eve of the Belmont Stakes with a career-ending injury to his left front tendon.
I'LL HAVE ANOTHER'S KENTUCKY DERBY WIN
Photo by Eclipse Sportswire
Given that experience, Reddam is more than willing to play catch-us-if-you-can with Mohaymen now and leave the future to the future. “A horse can get sick, he can bruise his foot, there is no guarantee we’re going to make the Kentucky Derby,” he said.
Reddam noted that the bittersweet experience with I’ll Have Another, also trained by O’Neill, led both men to be drawn to the five-week lead time to the Kentucky Derby that the Florida Derby offers. “We might have learned a few things about trying to keep our horse as fresh as possible,” he said.
O’Neill acknowledged that the perception of Mohaymen changed from the time they identified the seven-furlong San Vicente Stakes at Santa Anita and the Florida Derby as their means to arriving at Churchill Downs on the first Saturday in May.
“We didn’t know much about Mohaymen at that time,” O’Neill said. “He had won a couple of races in New York (Nashua and Remsen, both Grade 2). We never thought he’d be doing what he’s doing and we’d be doing what we’re doing. So that added to the mix, but we still think we are doing what is in the right interests of Nyquist.”
Nyquist earned a game 1 ½-length victory against Exaggerator in the San Vicente on Feb. 15 at Santa Anita in his 3-year-old debut for his sixth victory in as many starts, with five of those coming in California. Mohaymen boasts an unblemished 5-for-5 mark, having swept a pair of Grade 2 preps at Gulfstream while barely breaking a sweat.
Nyquist and Mohaymen are likely to press each other as they have never been pressed before. Reddam figured that into his thinking, too.
“Having to run hard might actually be good for our horse,” he said. “So that doesn’t bother me.”
$1-million Xpressbet Florida DerbyApril 2, Race 14, Gulfstream Park, 6:48 p.m. ET1 1/8 miles, dirt, 3-year-olds
PP
Horse
Jockey
Trainer
Owner(s)
Odds
1
Sawyers Mickey
Scott Spieth
Peter Walder
Loooch Racing Stables
TBD
2
Fellowship
Jose Lezcano
Stanley Gold
Jacks or Better Farm
TBD
3
Majesto
Javier Castellano
Gustavo Delgado
Grupo 7C Racing Stable
TBD
4
Nyquist
Mario Gutierrez
Doug O'Neill
Reddam Racing
TBD
5
Copingaway
Miguel A. Vasquez
Jaime Mejia
Thoroughbred Champions Training Center
TBD
6
Chovanes
Edgard Zayas
Jorge Navarro
Gelfenstein Farm
TBD
7
Takeittotheedge
Tyler Gaffalione
Dale Romans
Bakster Farm
TBD
8
Fashionable Freddy
Nik Juarez
Nick Zito
My Meadowview Farm
TBD
9
Mohaymen
Junior Alvarado
Kiaran McLaughlin
Shadwell Stable
TBD
10
Isofass
Julien Leparoux
Francis Abbott III
DB DOJO
TBD